from myths to reality
SEARCH
Tous les articles précédentsArticle précédent /
Partager sur Facebook(link is external)Partager sur Twitter(link is external)
Comets from Antiquity to the Middle Ages
Comets have always been the subject of wild speculation. The sudden and spectacular appearance of these objects was interpreted after the event as a harbinger of the major events. They were then supposed most often to announce some catastrophe, death, defeat or, sometimes victory. For example, Diodorus (90-30 BC) wrote in his Historical Library :
In the first year of the hundred and second Olympiad [372 BC] … several prodigies announced to the Spartans their humiliation to come: a burning torch of an extraordinary size, to which one gave the name of burning beam, appeared for several nights.
The medieval representations of comets were usually fanciful, and most often frightening. Besides the burning beam that returns repeatedly, we find swords and spears, inflamed or not, devouring monsters and hairy or bearded human heads, following again the Greek and Roman descriptions.
1 / 2
Aristote, gravure signée W.S, 16e siècle. Coll. Observatoire de Paris, inv.I.163
Crédit : Observatoire de Paris
Comets were considered as belonging to the sublunary world (closer than the Moon), which was supposed to be imperfect and subject to changes, while the supra-lunar world was perfect and unchanging. According to Aristotle, they were atmospheric phenomena, thus very close to us and therefore particularly formidable.
Amid these fantasies stands a remarkable character: the Roman Seneca (4 BC-65 AD), a Stoic philosopher, tutor and adviser to Emperor Nero, who forced Seneca to commit suicide after his disgrace. In his Natural Questions, Seneca devotes many lines to comets. He writes :
To facilitate our research, it will be good to consider whether comets are of the same nature as the bodies placed above them [the planets]. They have with them points of resemblance. […] Nothing confusing or tumultuous in their pace, nothing to suggest that they obey trouble elements and fickle mobiles. And then, even if these [atmospheric] vortices were strong enough to seize the humid fumes of the land and to throw them from so low to such heights [this is the idea of Aristotle on comets], they would not raise above the moon: all their action stops in the clouds. Now, we see comets riding very high in the heavens, among the stars. It is not likely that a vortex would subsist in such a long journey.
Les comètes comme des exhalaisons de la Terre, d’après Aristote. De cometis dissertationes novae clariss. / Thomas Erastus, Andreas Dudith, Marco Squarcialupi, Simon Grynaeus - Basilae, 1580 - p. 78
Crédit : Observatoire de Paris
Seneca thinks therefore, in opposition to Aristotle, that comets are not necessarily atmospheric phenomena, and may be more distant than the Moon. He adds :
Why be surprised that comets, which show themselves so rarely to the world, are not yet for us constrained by fixed laws, and that one does not know from where they come and where they will stop. [ … ] An age will come when what is mystery to us will be revealed by time and by the studies accumulated for centuries. […] Some day, a man will be born who will demonstrate where in the sky comets are wandering; why they move so quickly away from other planets [sic]; what are their size and nature.
This remarkable text, which calls for a scientific study of comets, contrasts with the passivity that would characterize for many centuries the philosopher’s successors.
With the guiding star, which was supposed to herald the birth of Christ, being often identified as a comet, ancient Christianity inverted the trend: comets might become favorable signs.
This is what appears in the representation of Halley’s Comet in the Bayeux Tapestry in France or in monastic illuminations. But we were still far from a scientific approach.
1 / 6
Fig. 9 : Phénomène observé lors du passage de la comète de l'an 214 avant J.-C ; Fig. 10 : Phénomène observé lors du passage de la comète de l'an 210 avant J-C, tiré de Die Wunder Gottes in der Natur, ben Erscheinung der Cometen, … / Conrado Lycosthenes [Wolfhart, de Rufach], 1744
Crédit : Observatoire de Paris
Tous les articles suivantsArticle suivant /
Keywords search
Top of Form
Bottom of Form
PERSON/INSTITUTION
- Apply Agence Spatiale Européenne (ESA) filterApply Agence Spatiale Européenne (ESA) filter
- Apply Aillaud G. J. filterApply Aillaud G. J. filter
- Apply Alfven H. filterApply Alfven H. filter
- Apply Anderson Bob filterApply Anderson Bob filter
- Apply Antosca Stéphanie filterApply Antosca Stéphanie filter
- Apply Apianus P. filterApply Apianus P. filter
- Apply Arago F. filterApply Arago F. filter
- Apply Araneda Cecilia filterApply Araneda Cecilia filter
- Apply Arthus G. filterApply Arthus G. filter
- Apply Baldet F. filterApply Baldet F. filter
- Apply Bartholinus E. filterApply Bartholinus E. filter
- Apply Bay Michael filterApply Bay Michael filter
- Apply Bayle P. filterApply Bayle P. filter
- Apply Belot J. filterApply Belot J. filter
- Apply Bernoulli J. filterApply Bernoulli J. filter
- Apply Bertaux J.-L. filterApply Bertaux J.-L. filter
- Apply Bessel F. W filterApply Bessel F. W filter
- Apply Bibring J.-P. filterApply Bibring J.-P. filter
- Apply Biermann l. filterApply Biermann l. filter
- Apply Binkowski Arthur F. filterApply Binkowski Arthur F. filter
THEMATIC
- Apply Fiction filterApply Fiction filter
- Apply Films scientifiques filterApply Films scientifiques filter
- Apply History filterApply History filter
- Apply Science filterApply Science filter
YEAR
- Apply 1472 filterApply 1472 filter
- Apply 1531 filterApply 1531 filter
- Apply 1540 filterApply 1540 filter
- Apply 1556 filterApply 1556 filter
- Apply 1573 filterApply 1573 filter
- Apply 1577 filterApply 1577 filter
- Apply 1578 filterApply 1578 filter
- Apply 1579 filterApply 1579 filter
- Apply 1580 filterApply 1580 filter
- Apply 1596 filterApply 1596 filter
- Apply 1618 filterApply 1618 filter
- Apply 1619 filterApply 1619 filter
- Apply 1664 filterApply 1664 filter
- Apply 1665 filterApply 1665 filter
- Apply 1666 filterApply 1666 filter
- Apply 1680 filterApply 1680 filter
- Apply 1681 filterApply 1681 filter
- Apply 1682 filterApply 1682 filter
- Apply 1744 filterApply 1744 filter
- Apply 1759 filterApply 1759 filter
TYPE
- Apply "Hunters" record filterApply "Hunters" record filter
- Apply Bibliographic record filterApply Bibliographic record filter
- Apply Comets record filterApply Comets record filter
- Apply History and sciences page filterApply History and sciences page filter
- Apply Movie record filterApply Movie record filter
L'observatoire de ParisPSL Research University